Body Bags In the News Every Day

During the Vietnam War the American public was continuously fed enemy casualty statistics in order to bolster the perception that we were winning that war. Today with the ongoing war in Iraq we are continuously fed casualty statistics, but it is not the enemy’s body count we are getting, it is not the military or political leadership that is doing the feeding, and it is sure as hell is not a perception of winning that is being bolstered.

About a month ago neo-neocon wrote a thoughtful piece on the effect casualty statistics have on public opinion. I just want to ask this one question:

Is the mainstream news media’s daily recitation of dead and injured in Iraq and Afghanistan valuable to you?

Perhaps it is, and if so I’d be interested to hear in what way. To me it frankly ain’t. I don’t need to know the details about who died from what car bomb at what time in what province each day in order to honor the sacrifice our servicemen are making. I don’t gain information from mere casualty reports that is of any significant value in assessing the war strategically; outlets like Strategy Page, INDC Journal, and The Fourth Rail are infinitely more useful in that regard. Nor are the daily recitations helpful to me in making cost evaluations of the worthiness of the war effort as a whole–I’m well aware of how many have died to date, and there is so very much more that goes into a cost/benefit evaluation than this one statistic.

The only valuable service I can think of that these daily reports provide is to remind the chronically oblivious that yes, there is a war going on in a faraway place you may not know or care about. But how valuable this one service really is may be debatable.

Advertisements

2 responses to “Body Bags In the News Every Day

  1. I usually find it crass when talking heads on the news squeeze the number of dead US soldiers in between the cost of gas at the pump and a new report on how chocolate may not be as bad for you as you think. It has always seemed disrespectful to me to nonchalantly mention our war casualties.

  2. I wonder if that occurs to them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s